If an engine needs to be removed from the vehicle to perform repairs, replacing the engine with a remanufactured motor can be more beneficial than an overhaul. This article discusses the advantages of a replacement versus an overhaul repair. In some instances a replacement can actually be cheaper than a repair. Even if a repair shop quotes a lower price for an overhaul repair, there are other advantages to a complete remanufactured engine replacement.
Why a Repair Shop May Suggest an Engine Overhaul
An auto repair shop may try to persuade the customer to overhaul an engine instead of replacing it with a remanufactured engine simply because there’s more profit. There’s a lot of competition with remanufactured engines and the gross profit can be a lot less than overhaul parts. There’s usually a lot more labor involved in an overhaul compared to a replacement. More labor and repair parts translate into more profits for the repair shop.
Advantages of a Remanufactured Engine Replacement
Beside a cost advantage in some cases, there are other advantages that can save the car owner money in the long run. There are three basic advantages to a remanufactured engine exchange versus an engine overhaul repair.
- warranty
- quality
- time
Generally a remanufactured car engine will have a warranty that is far superior to an overhaul repair. There are engine suppliers that will offer a 3 year or 100,000 mile warranty, which ever comes first. If an auto repair shop suggests an overhaul repair, ask them what the warranty is for the repair versus a motor exchange.
When an engine is overhauled, the quality of the repair is dependent on the experience and knowledge of the auto technician. Remanufactured units are often dynamometer tested to ensure the integrity and quality of the motor. Ask the repair shop how their remanufactured engines are tested. Using a genuine factory rebuilt engine is also a good option for quality and nationwide warranty.
Naturally if there’s more labor involved, an overhaul repair will take longer. There’s also the fact that a lot of parts maybe required for an overhaul, running the risk of backordered parts conditions. If the car owner’s renting a replacement vehicle, the rental will also add to the repair expense.
Preventing Costly Engine Repairs
Pay close attention to the engine oil pressure and coolant temperature gauges if equipped. If the oil pressure gauge, temperature gauge or check engine light is in the red, safely shut off the engine and have the vehicle towed to a repair shop.
If there are flooded road conditions, use extreme care. Water can be sucked into the engine from the air filter intake causing sever engine damage. Other prevention steps include:
- adhering to a routine vehicle maintenance schedule
- using the correct engine oil classification for the car’s engine.
- performing routine vehicle engine inspections
When major engine repairs are needed, it’s a good idea to get several quotes. Contact various auto repair shops to get the best price. Ask each shop the warranty coverage on their remanufactured engines, as well as the quality testing procedures. Make sure the auto repair shop can start on the repairs right away
James Clausen - Clausen received a Bachelors Degree in Business Administration in Automotive Management and Marketing at Northwood University, graduating ...
Join the Conversation